Sunday, May 19, 2013

Latest local news, weather and high school sports for Northern Michigan

Robert Schwander murder trial day 4
Posted: 10.25.2011 at 10:57 AM
Updated: 10.25.2011 at 8:50 PM
25

Defense calls Robert Schwander to the stand

Photo

TRAVERSE CITY -- After four days of testimony, the prosecution rested its case.

Robert Jensen Schwander, the teen accused of killing Carly Lewis took the stand in his own defense.

Dressed in a light green shirt, Schwander calmly told jurors he killed Carly, and that it was an accident. From there, it was back to the beginning. Schwander explained that he became homeless after his parents kicked him out of the house in December for sneaking out late at night.

Schwander testified that living on his own was difficult. He said he moved from friend's home to friend's home and even spent the night in a homeless shelter. He said he lost 15 pounds because he wasn't getting enough food.

He also told jurors that one family kicked him out after they found a bong in the home. Schwander knew Carly's brother Mitchell, and eventually moved into the Lewis home. Schwander said at first he and Carly didn't get along, but that they eventually became friends, and even smoked marijuana together.

Earlier Tuesday, Thomas Holcolmb, a crime scene investigator testified that he was the one using a probe at the crime scene to help find Carly's body. He testified that it was likely the probe put holes in the garbage bag Carly was wrapped in. Holcolmb also testified that no clear fingerprints were found on the scissors that were found on the scene and could have been used kill Carly.

In cross examination the defense criticized Holcolmb for only taking 16 pictures of the body wrapped in a plastic bag and 179 of the area around the crime scene.

Nicole Graham, a forensic scientist with Michigan State Police testified that Carly's blood was found on scissors found at the scene but not on a knife that Schwander had in his possession.

The prosecution rested its case shortly after 11 a.m.

On Friday a local teacher testified that he exchanged letters with Schwander and even visited him in jail. He said that Schwander talked about evil spirits taking over him.

Schwander's close friends tearfully testified against him telling the juror he asked them to lie about his whereabouts during the two weeks Carly Lewis was missing.

Even though the prosecution hadn't finished with it's witness testimony, the defense was allowed to call its medical examiner to testify.

Washtenaw County Chief Medical Examiner, Dr. Bader Cassin testified that the stab wounds found on Carly's body did not kill her, and that it is possible she was strangled. That counters the prosecution's claim that Carly died from one of the ten stab wounds found on her body.

Robert Jensen Schwander will be back on the stand Wednesday morning to finish his testimony.

Popular Stories
Thumbnail
Woman pinned underneath car after rollover accident
Yesterday at 4:02 PM  |  6 comments
Thumbnail
Man crashes car into ditch then breaks into nearby house
Kate Fox  |  Yesterday at 5:54 PM  |  2 comments
Thumbnail
Man barricaded in Osceola County home, may have hostages
Erika Erickson  |  Friday, May 17, 2013  |  6 comments
Follow Up North Live
Get news and weather notifications on your phone by downloading the iPhone or Android app below
Sign up to get alerts and updates for breaking news, severe weather, and deals:
submit
ADVERTISEMENT
Special Features
ADVERTISEMENT