Fact Finder: Hatchery Runs Dry, Fewer Fish Watch Video Read Comments
ADVERTISEMENT
Photo
By Marc Schollett
Monday, October 05, 2009 at 10:15 a.m.

Read more: Local, Fact, Finder, Hatchery, Orsini, Dnr, Steelhead, Marc, Schollett, Fact Finder

When it comes to explaining the lure of raising the trophy fish of tomorrow at his privately owned hatchery, Frank Orsini sounds an awful lot like a proud parent. "It's just a great experience. I like to see these little critters, just feeding them and watching them grow, and to know what they are going to do. From here they go up to the big lake, and then all the sport fishermen are able to reap the benefits."

This time of year, Orsini should be a pretty busy man, cleaning tanks and raceways used to raise steel heads in Manistee County. Orsini explains "the fish arrive here around the second week of November and they are 2 to 4 inches long. We will take those fish and raise them all until they are 6 to 10 inches long. The idea is by the time they hit the Betsie the bigger fish will go out right away the smaller fish may stay for awhile, might stay till next spring, but hopefully we want to see them go out to the big lake, Lake Michigan and people will fish them in the river and in the lake."

For years, Orsini has been able to watch those fish grow over the winter, sometimes in numbers that are staggering. As Orsini recalls, "there have been years when we have had as many as 50,000, but the last 3 to 4 years we have been somewhat less, 30 to 35, and the last couple of years the high 20's, 26 or 27 thousand."

But this year, the scene looks very different at one of the few private fish hatcheries in the entire state. The reason is money. In the past the DNR has provided the hatchery with the tens of thousands of fry, and covered the cost of trucking, food, fin clipping and some of the electrical costs for raising the fish till spring, when they would be released. Orsini says "We just don't have the funding this year that we need. The DNR is down and they have a cutback from the state of Michigan, so we don't know exactly what they can and can not do at this point."

But the bigger problem in terms of money is spelled out clearly in a letter from the Manistee County Sport Fishing Association. The association's board voted against funding the $15,000 needed to cover this year's fish expenses as they have in the past. This year they voted instead to mothball the Orsini hatchery project for the fall's fish cycle, citing their own budget shortfalls. Orsini says he understands the economic situation for both the DNR and the Sports Fishing Association, but worries what the long term impact will be. The DNR already has hatched the tiny fish that were slated to be delivered to the hatchery in November. So if the Orsini Hatchery doesn't have the money to raise them this year, the DNR says they will most likely just release the fish this fall and Orsini says "at that little fry stage they survival rate is going to be far far less then if they were 6 to 8 inches long."

So it appears, unless an individual or group comes forward to fund the project in the next few days, these tanks will sit empty this fall and fish won't be released come next spring on the Betsie. While that might not impact the fishing this year, Orsini believes it will when the trophies are no longer out in Lake Michigan, "the impact is not going to be this year and it might not be next year but it will be the 3rd and 4th year when there is that many less fish that got big."

So what do you think? Let me know. Leave a comment below.

SPONSORED CONTENT
10 Comments on this Story
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them; they are not reflective of the views or opinions of Barrington Broadcasting, TV 7&4, its directors or employees. If you believe a comment violates the Barrington Terms of Use, please report it here.

Steelhead

Posted by Tim Sed, Kalamazoo - Monday, October 12, 2009 at 10:27 p.m.

Let them breed on there own like they've done for generations eh? Too many steelhead? The only reason these fish are in our lakes and rivers is because of efforts of the MDNR. Salmon and trout(including steelhead)are not native fish and without the DNR regulating and controlling planting and spawning efforts, Michigan would not have the fishery we have today. Our efforts and money built this fishery so why waste it? Where are the millions of dollars in revenue from fishing licenses going???? I know where it should be going!!! Right back into the fishery!!! As for too many steelhead, our fishery is a fraction of what it was in the past!! OPEN YOUR EYES

Are you people stupid?

Posted by Bryan mallison, Ludington - Friday, October 09, 2009 at 11:39 a.m.

Fishing is huge part of our economy here in Northern MI. There are a lot of businesses that depend on fishing to bring in customers. People come from all over the country to fish in our lakes and rivers. So why would you idiots not want to support this hatchery.

I like jon none's comment. "there are far to many steelies." This guy obviously has no clue about our steelhead fishery. You people should be supporting this guy for doing what he is doing. Chances are, if you are business owner in Northern Michigan, you have had customers in your business that came here just to fish.

So you people need to wake up. This man is doing a great thing.

Let's just let them do it on their own...

Posted by Acme Pete, TC - Tuesday, October 06, 2009 at 2:09 p.m.

Here's a unique thought: Pull all the wier's out of all the river's, let all the fish do what they did for generations before the DNR came along by going up river and spawning/reproducing on their own...

As far as this business going down, You are providing a service and the people of michigan paid all your bills, sounds good to me, but you gotta expect the plug to be pulled at some point. A real business pays their own bills, doesn't require subsidies and is able to produce a product without a cost to tax payers...

steelhead and perch

Posted by wes yemmans, mesick - Tuesday, October 06, 2009 at 11:27 a.m.

I read the posts so I called some friends,charter boat capatins.
I asked and all said they have Never found a perch in a steelhead. the perch decline is most likeley do to birds.Gobys
and also they seem to run in cycles.Steelhead in the betsie bring in people to benzie county.Lake fishing as well as river fishing.The Orsini hachery has helped bring money into our area as well as educating school children for over 10 years.rivers are more then a place to fish the are part of our soul.Fishing is to many people there way to excape.No fish people will go to other areas not ours.

Where did the money go?

Posted by robert lux, manistee - Monday, October 05, 2009 at 8:11 p.m.

What happend to the money we sportsman voted on a few years ago,so the liscense fees would all go for fishing and hunting? There should be money left over for stocking fish for the Great Lakes......This is a drop in the bucket. No Fish, means no tourist,which means no motels,Charters,Gas,Food,sale of fishing gear, ect,ect. Get the Idea!!!!!!!!!!!!!! We need to vote you all out, and start over, You still don't get it!!!But you will. Signed, Had enough in Manistee Bob

MDNR not at fault

Posted by Fish Buster, Manistee - Monday, October 05, 2009 at 7:11 p.m.

Where is the money for all species license going?
Here is another example of the way our state reps and others cannot balance a budget. Just shut the whole state of Michigan down, we are broke anyway.

MDNR not at fault

Posted by Fish Buster, Manistee - Monday, October 05, 2009 at 7:09 p.m.

Where is the money for all species license going?
Here is another example of the way our state reps and others cannot balance a budget. Just shut the whole state of Michigan down, we are broke anyway.

Perfect Example!

Posted by Sharon N., T.C. - Monday, October 05, 2009 at 3:03 p.m.

This is a perfect example of funding cuts that so desperately need to be done in this state. I'm sure the majority of people have no clue we pay Mr. Orsini $15,000.00 a year to sustain his fish hatchery to grow trophy size fish. And, per the previous comments from charter fishermen, these trophy fish are eating millions of smaller fish, i.e. the perch.
Let's let nature take its course in the fish world and save this state $15,000.00.
But an even bigger question to me is, how many other Mr. Orsini's are out there and how much could we, the taxpayer, save if they were all exposed?
I harbor no ill-will towards Mr. Orsini but this state must rein in it's out-of-control spending spree that has gone on for years and give some tax relief to it's citizens so we can all recover from this dismal economy.

Mr.

Posted by AL HUBERT, Mancelona Mi. - Monday, October 05, 2009 at 12:45 p.m.

This kind of selective breading can alter the balance of nature. I agree with John None 100%

dont bother me any

Posted by John none, Northern MI - Monday, October 05, 2009 at 11:28 a.m.

I am sorry this man livelyhood is going down the tubes but there are far to many steelies now and they have been taking a toll on the perch maybe this will give the perch a chance to rebound, I used to work on a charter boat and seen steelhead and salmon just filled to the brim with perch

News
ADVERTISEMENT

PopularCommented


CONSUMER INFO