Fact Finder: Early Childhood Cuts Watch Video Read Comments
ADVERTISEMENT
Photo

How Lawmakers' Plans to Balance the State Budget May Impact Young Children and Their Families

By Diana Fairbanks
Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 1:59 p.m.

Read more: Local, State, Economy, Politics, Daycare, Early Childhood, Lawmakers, Leelanau, Diana Fairbanks, Fact Finder, Fact Finder

State lawmakers are now back in Lansing after their 4th of July break and the budget is job number one as they try to figure out a way to make ends meet.

We've told you about some of the proposed cuts including cuts to k-12 and higher education, but there are also hundreds of millions of dollars in proposed cuts that would affect even younger kids and their families, which could have even longer lasting consequences.

In tonight's Fact Finder Report, we take a closer look at what's at stake.

For the last 30 years The Leelanau Children's Center has grown from meeting in a church basement to a nationally recognized network for early childhood education.

They offer many services with one goal: building a solid foundation during a critical time in development.

Leelanau Children's Center Executive Director Maggie Sprattmoran says,

"The architecture of the brain that gets developed by age five is the foundation upon which all other learning will rest."

She says the benefits are more than just theory.

Sprattmoran says, "When we do a great job in these early years we see a ton less neglect, we see a ton less special education, a ton less teen pregnancy, crime in the teen years, higher graduation rates, more kids go to college, more kids become tax paying citizens rather than people relying on services."

Half of their million dollar budget comes from tuition and endowments; the other half comes from the state through the Department of Education and the Department of Human Services.

But if the plan currently on the table in Lansing goes through, that half of the center's budget would disappear.

Sprattmoran says, "We could see the dismantling of these programs that have proven to be really incredibly successful."

That includes the funding that provides scholarships to more than half of the center's families.

Sprattmoran says, "We work super hard to provide services to anyone who wants to participate here. Whether you speak English or not, whether you have a special need child, whether you have a higher income, or low income. Everybody gets to walk in this door. We depend on those government sources to help subsidize some of those families who can't pay full tuition."

That includes parents like Amy Schettek who can only get part time work right now.

Amy says, "If I didn't have the funding he just wouldn't go to school, it's very important to me that he does get this early childhood education."

Anne Shoup's family joined the growing list of families who need financial assistance last year when her husband who is a teacher couldn't find work.

Shoup says "we had to make a hard decision last fall and had to call the Children's Center and said we can't make this go this year."

Thanks to scholarships, both Schettek and the Shoup's could keep their children at the center last year.

But with serious funding cuts on the line, what will happen this year is less clear.

Sprattmoran says, "it certainly means we can't scholarship all of those families we've been scholarshipping. Does it mean these high quality programs become inaccessible to anybody bit the wealthy? That seems unacceptable to me. I don't know what the answer will be, and I am worried about it."

Educators and parents say that could mean some parents having to quit their jobs and turn to welfare because childcare without scholarships cost more than they make.

Sprattmoran says, "It's a complicated story. We forget supporting parents who go to work support our economy."

Sheytek says, "They're going to see a lot more moms, not giving up, just losing hope."

The Leelanau Children's Center is not alone, these cuts would affect countless programs and childcare centers throughout the state.

All of the parents and educators I talked with say they know our lawmakers are in a tough situation, but they say these programs are essential and it's up to citizens to call legislators and let them know what matters.

So what matters to you? What do you think is too essential to cut?

I want to hear from you, leave your comments below.

Click here to read a detailed list of the proposed cuts that would impact early childhood programs.

If you would like to tell your state lawmakers what's important to you, click here to contact your representative, click here to contact your senator.

SPONSORED CONTENT
22 Comments on this Story
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them; they are not reflective of the views or opinions of Barrington Broadcasting, TV 7&4, its directors or employees. If you believe a comment violates the Barrington Terms of Use, please report it here.

daycare provider

Posted by Emily Hansen, Cheboygan - Saturday, July 25, 2009 at 1:08 p.m.

I think its terrible that the state is considering cutting early development. As a daycare provider I see all kinds of kids with different development. Some come into my care very intellgent others dont have a chance. Not trying to sound mean but not all kids are the same. Some need that extra help. Lets just face theres some parents out that dont give crap if there child learns or not. This program is there for the kids to actually have a chance in life. Not to turn out like there selfish parents who dont give a darn. The state already complains that the prisons in this area is full. What the heck do they think it will look like in 15 yrs when these lil ones dont get the help now. We need to save the children now and not wait til its to late!!!! Save the program!

Early Childhood Educator

Posted by Jamie Gapczynski, Cheboygan - Saturday, July 25, 2009 at 11:24 a.m.

As a early childhood educator I am greatly insulted by the quote, "I think early childhood is glorified babysitting" left by "I say no". I can tell you first hand it is definitely NOT glorified babysitting. Do you know almost all of us are required to have Masters, Bachelors, or Associate degrees? We all have to have updated training every year. We are your children's first connection between home and school and we work our butts off to make that a good transition. We lay the foundation for your children to be successful in school. We help transition your children to be able to successfully socialize with their peers. "Studies have shown that the benefits of early childhood programs far outweigh the costs, and if there is one thing we should be investing in to secure the future of Michigan's economy, it's OUR children" Sen. Deb Cherry.

It's not just about preschool. It's about quality childcare for those who can't afford it. It's about necessary health services for those who can't afford it. It's about children with special needs who are able to get services they otherwise wouldn't. It's not just about losing my job. It's about the 34 children on my "tentative" roster for this fall! It is the lowest that Michigan can go, to take away services from innocent at risk children. It is heartbreaking.

Change

Posted by Cadillac Citizen, Cadillac - Wednesday, July 22, 2009 at 8:34 a.m.

I say take some benefits from the prisoners and keep the kids in school!

Some things can't be taught at home....

Posted by Working Mom, Houghton - Tuesday, July 21, 2009 at 9:20 a.m.

I don't typically comment on things here, however this time I finally have to. I have taught my children (2 boys) the alphabet, how to count, my 6 year old can add and subtract, count money, and my children have excellent manners, thank you very much. However, I was grateful for the pre-K programs open to them through BHK for one very big reason. It helped them with socializing skills, following routine, and being in with a larger group of kids. Sorry to the perfect parents out there that are able to do it all themselves, but I wasn't. I couldn't teach my 4 year old about circle time and the importance of sitting still within it, (just an example) because I can't do a circle time. So just because I am all for pre-K education, and yes, I am willing to pay taxes to go towards it, doesn't also mean that I am an inadequate parent.

I also see the point of people who say, I don't have kids, why should I have to pay? Can't say that I blame them for that side of the argument.

cuts for early childhood

Posted by Melanie Bredbanner, Benzonia - Monday, July 20, 2009 at 7:30 p.m.

I am very disappointed to hear that they want to cut early childhood programs. Every young child deserves a chance to learn and be able to interact with others. I think it is very important that the lawmakers think this over before they do so because there will be a lot of people who will not be able to work anymore because of lack or no funding for early childhood classrooms. Not to mention all the teaching staff of those classrooms who have to shut down that will be out of a job. I think it is unfair and as a state we should be advocating that our children should not suffer.

Parenting

Posted by Amy in Charlevoix, Charlevoix - Monday, July 20, 2009 at 2:10 p.m.

To the poster by the name of Traverse City
You wrote "What ever happened to parents being parents?"

These early childhood programs aren't just for teaching parents how to teach their children. They are for helping parents get their G.E.D.'s so that they can effectively parent and be productive members of society and reduce the chances of their children living in poverty, as well as going to jail later in life.

The programs help parents of all socioeconomic statuses and educational backgrounds. I know parents who have college degrees but utilize these programs because their children have developmental disabilities. Even though these parents are prepared to have children they still need help.

I work with children and their families. These families work hard to educate their children as well as put food on the table and with the way the economy is going, it is more difficult for parents to do both and that is why families need our help and support more than ever.

I am Traverse City

Posted by I am Traverse City I am Traverse City, Traverse City - Monday, July 20, 2009 at 1:32 p.m.

Teaching a child is not a difficult thing to do!!! Have you ever heard of making the most of your time with your kids? For all of you that are asking...yes I do have children, if you think that teaching a toddler is difficult try it when they get into middle school adn high school and are also involved in sports and many other activities! You can complain all you want about not having enough time to teach your kids, but in the end what do you do while in the car with your kids????? You can teach numbers and letters and the alphabet and all kinds of other things in the car or with soap in the bath tub or during dinner..... Come on people, you had the time to make these children...IT IS TIME TO STEP UP AND BE A PARENT TO THEM! If those of us with older kids cal teach freakin geometry and calc. driving our kids to their sporting events than you can surely teach younger kids what they need to know. How about teaching them manners and that the parents wear the pants instead of letting your kids rule your life!!!

i say no

Posted by m h, ishpeming - Monday, July 20, 2009 at 12:06 p.m.

I do believe that parents need to step up to the plate and start teaching their own toddlers whatever they feel is necessary. Our government is getting way too big and yes they do threaten services are going to be cut if the tax payers dont start coughing up more money! Enough already! I do agree that they threaten until they get what they want and then its off to some other crisis some govt. agency is having. Some people are more than willing to pay higher taxes, but I have a problem with this way of thinking because when the govt screams there isnt enough money, they are only refering to their pay check cuts, not the services they provide. And we the tax payers keep paying more while the govt keeps spending so foolishly.
I think that this early childhood education is glorified babysitting! The parents need to start taking more responcibility all the way around. Some people say by the time the parents get home from working, their too tired to do anything with the kids. Well they weren't too tired to create the child, so that is a terrible excuse.This education reasoning of "Michigan ranks 27th in the country" is a bunch of bull too. The teachers we have today k-12 should be made to get back to the basics. And we need to eliminate "No child left behind." This in itself is proving to be a useless federal legislation issue.
So all in all I say no to funding early childhood education. (And for anyone who wants to ask or make a comment that I don't have children -FYI I do!)

YOUR choice, NOT mine!!

Posted by jenna modean, yooper - Saturday, July 18, 2009 at 1:38 p.m.

When you choose to have children, you should also be choosing to shoulder the expense of having them. While early childhood education is important, why should childless couples and the elderly be taxed to pay for YOUR decision?

Tax increase? Who are you kidding?

Posted by Judy Hammond, Traverse City - Friday, July 17, 2009 at 2:49 p.m.

Every time the government wants to raise our taxes, they toss out a program like this one as a scare tactic. Does anyone really believe that a tax increase would go toward education? Our state leaders keep pushing these increases on us, but the promised benefits do not materialize. The programs that are threatened are usually education, Social Security, Veterans' benefits, or Medicaid. Threats to these programs produce strong emotional reactions, which is exactly what Lansing wants. Then when they get the increase that they want, another emergency arises and the money is spent elsewhere.

"Early Childhood Cuts"

Posted by Bill Perault, Cheboygan - Friday, July 17, 2009 at 2:05 p.m.

You wanted to hear from us what we thought was essential to cut, well how about those raises that our state seems to keep getting? Cant we cut that? How about all the non-essential goverment spending going on, cant we cut that? How many offices are set up to watch another office to make sure they are doing their job "in the best interest" of michigan? There is another fact finder for ya, check out what that means, "in the best interest of the state of Michigan". You will find that sometimes it is in the States best interest to allow mistakes on forms so that the state can disqualify persons that are qualified for what ever services or business programs and so on. We, as the people, need to start standing up and saying enough is enough. It was us hard working men and women that made what we have today, how come we are letting them tax us improperly, "without proper and legal representation"? All I see is they can no longer afford this and thats but our taxes remain the same and are going up still. Am I the only 1 who is noticing this? My e-mail should be posted, e-mail me someone, let me know.

Yes, we do need early childhood education!

Posted by Mike Acosta, Traverse City - Friday, July 17, 2009 at 11:03 a.m.

I have a couple of problems with the comment coming from the oerson who chooses to be identified only as "Traverse City". First they say we need child care so a parent can work but fails to connect the fact that most young children have both parents in the workforce and therefore don't have the time or energy at the end of the day to do all that it takes to be your child's first and best teacher. Besides all parents need some support, including stay at home parents who do have the time and energy to be with thier kids all day. Early childhood education is not just about classrooms but also about providing information and resources for the parents of children from the time thsy take the child home form the hospital.
Secondly, the writer says the state can't give away money it doesn't have; but it does! Consider tax loopholes (or "tax expenditures) as one way that the state does give away money before it even collects it. These exceptions to tax laws are granted by the legislature and rarely reconsidered. Also the state choose to give away money it didn't have when our last governor and his political allies choose to reduce tax rates with the full knowledge that they were leaving the state with insufficient revenues to accomplish what citizens had come to expect from the state. These folks did not identify the kind of painful cuts we are currently experiencing but made up the difference in one-time fixes until they were long gone, leaving others to clean up the mess they had created!

Step Up and Be Parents, And Partner With Your Early Childhood Educators!

Posted by Stephanie McCown, Bellaire - Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 11:31 p.m.

I have a six month old son whose favorite activity is to cuddle with me and read a few books. I have been reading to him since he was in the womb, and it is the best way to calm him when he's restless or hyper. He truly enjoys listening to my voice, watching as I point out colors and shapes to him, count with him, and so forth.

I'm also teaching him ASL, and he is beginning to recognize that the sign for "milk", "finished", "more", etc., actually mean something.

I do not talk baby talk to him, which often renders odd looks from those who listen to me talk to my son. However, I see no point in talking baby talk to him when he will not be encouraged to talk baby talk when he enters school.

I am a good mother who uses those wonderful "teaching moments" to guide my son the best that I can. I know my son is capable of learning even at his young age, and I intend to teach him the best that I can.

That said, I know that I do not know everything, and that the standards for kindergarten preparedness are much higher than simply knowing his ABCs and being able to count.

I think we have well established that early childhood education has long term benefits to both the child, and the community he or she is a part of. Additionally, there are benefits in the short-term that extremely valuable for the child as he or she goes into kindergarten.

Yes, we do need to be working with our kids and teaching them as much as we can at home. However, early childhood educators are much more aware of what is expected of children as they enter kindergarten, and can better prepare our kids for the transition.

Kindergarten is not what it used to be. The standards are much higher than they were when I was in kindergarten twenty years ago. I know of several children who are intelligent, savvy kids who are more than capable of counting, saying their ABCs, and writing their names, yet did not pass the pre-kindergarten assessment administered by the school. Children who do not pass the assessment may ultimately fail kindergarten, possibly putting them on the path for struggling the entire way through school.

Why not partner with your early childhood educators to ensure that your child has the best possible future? We can teach our kids many of the basics ourselves, but I prefer to allow those who have a greater awareness of what is expected of our kids to pick up where I leave off.

If for no other reason than to help our kids avoid being labeled by the teachers, or made fun of by the other kids for failing kindergarten, I think the investment in early childhood education is well worth whatever money is spent.

Of course, we know the benefits of early childhood education reach far beyond passing kindergarten, and cutting these programs hurts all of us and endangers our state even further.

reply to comments

Posted by Jen Whisler, Central Lake - Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 10:42 p.m.

@ Bill: Yes, I was directing my post to the poster that is at the very bottom of this page.

@Sara: I am glad I am not the only one who is willing to see an increase in sales tax. There is another option of raising tax on beer as well.

To all:
Like I said in my original post, I am a busy mom of five, all 5 years old and younger. I work two part time jobs and I go to college full time. I am working hard on being a good role model and leader for my children. While doing that I also have to sacrifice some of the time that my children would normally get from me, and therefore I cannot teach them all by myself. That is not to say that I do not teach them, because I do...I am an active teacher in their lives, but I cannot do it all. Another fact is that the "free" (state funded) preschool options help people get out and work. I would much rather have a child in preschool than in daycare.

reply to comments

Posted by Jen Whisler, Central Lake - Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 10:42 p.m.

@ Bill: Yes, I was directing my post to the poster that is at the very bottom of this page.

@Sara: I am glad I am not the only one who is willing to see an increase in sales tax. There is another option of raising tax on beer as well.

To all:
Like I said in my original post, I am a busy mom of five, all 5 years old and younger. I work two part time jobs and I go to college full time. I am working hard on being a good role model and leader for my children. While doing that I also have to sacrifice some of the time that my children would normally get from me, and therefore I cannot teach them all by myself. That is not to say that I do not teach them, because I do...I am an active teacher in their lives, but I cannot do it all. Another fact is that the "free" (state funded) preschool options help people get out and work. I would much rather have a child in preschool than in daycare.

Pay now or pay later....

Posted by Bill Tullet, Petoskey - Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 10:26 p.m.

Ms. Whisler, I agree with your thinking, but I do hope that your post was not directed to the city of Traverse City, I am assuming it was to the person who posted in an anonymous fashion at the very bottom.

To everyone else,

We will all pay for the cuts and/or elimination to these early education programs. It has been proven that programs that help children learn in the preschool years help them throughout their lives. If we do not fund these programs now, we will pay for these children who do not succeed later. The children that are eligible for these programs are often impoverished, or face a challenge that is difficult to overcome. Some of these children will be forced to be stuck in the same cycle as their parents if they are not given the chance to change their lives. I, personally, would much rather pay for a child's pre-k education. Would you rather pay for that child to be stuck in special education classes because he or she is always behind and then have them end up in prison where we will pay to feed, clothe, and keep them healthy while locked up?

The cost in the long run is greater than if we pay now. Just my two cents.

Raise my taxes please!

Posted by Sara Hillman, Traverse City - Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 10:10 p.m.

I am strongly against elimination of early childhood education. These are programs that are needed. Children do not get the quality time with parents like they used to.

I would prefer that Michigan's sales tax be increased. If we increased the sales tax to just $.07 on the dollar we would be able to bring in plenty of revenue to stop the elimination of these programs.

As I read over the proposed cuts, I was appalled to see that school bus inspections were on the chopping block!

PLEASE, RAISE OUR TAXES!

Raise my taxes please!

Posted by Sara Hillman, Traverse City - Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 10:10 p.m.

I am strongly against elimination of early childhood education. These are programs that are needed. Children do not get the quality time with parents like they used to.

I would prefer that Michigan's sales tax be increased. If we increased the sales tax to just $.07 on the dollar we would be able to bring in plenty of revenue to stop the elimination of these programs.

As I read over the proposed cuts, I was appalled to see that school bus inspections were on the chopping block!

PLEASE, RAISE OUR TAXES!

To "Traverse City"

Posted by Jen Whisler, Central Lake - Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 10:03 p.m.

Early childhood education programs do not just teach children, they become a partner with the parents in order to ensure the children are being taught in both the home, and at school.

What happened to parents teaching children, you ask...the economy, the education standards, and today's society happened. School is much more difficult today than it was even 10 years ago. Kindergartners are expected to know more and learn more than in years before. Today there are few stay at home parents, and all too many single parents. To make it in today's world both parents must often work, and in a single parent home it is even more difficult to have enough time to teach a child all s/he needs to know.

I am not sure if you have children, if you do, you should know how busy life is and not every child gets parents that know how to teach them either. Most of the funding is for "at risk" children that have certain environmental factors that may leave them behind in learning.

Honestly though, why on Earth would you want to cut something that is so beneficial? These are the people who will be our future government officials, our doctors, nurses, and other caregivers. These children are the future of the world! Why would you want to make them suffer for our poor economy?

Early childhood education is the best investment we can make right now. I encourage you to go to www.heckmanequation.org and view the slideshow.

What are they thinking?

Posted by Jen Whisler, Central Lake - Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 5:03 p.m.

I am amazed at our legislator's choice to balance the budget by cutting Michigan's early childhood education programs! It has been proven that birth to age five are the most important years in a child's development. Michigan already ranks 27th in the country for age 0-5 funding, do we really need to get any worse? The economy IS tough, and because of that everyone is thinking short term solution. Well, the truth is, short term solutions will lead to always needing short term solutions. We need to start thinking long term. Early childhood education is really an investment in our future. The more we focus on children truly being ready for kindergarten and able to learn well throughout their school career, the better Michigan's future will be. If children are healthy and ready to learn, they will learn more and go further than if they are struggling with basic concepts and other issues in their lives. Preschool programs help ensure that children are ready for kindergarten intellectually, and emotionally. Take away preschool funding and you take away many childrens' chance to interact with other children and learn the social skills necessary. Kindergarten, along with the rest of school, is more demanding. We expect more out of children, and yet parents aren't able to prepare children on their own. In this busy world with this difficult economy most families have to have both parents work, and where does that leave the child? With a childcare provider. With these essential early childhood programs children can go to a safe place where they can be adequately prepared for kindergarten. As a mom of five children age five and under, I know how challenging life can be. I also know how much preschool programs have benefited three of my children. I would hate to see children not have the same opportunities as three of my boys, and I would really hate to see my other two children not get the same great start in education as their brothers. Michigan's legislators need to re-evaluate their decisions and look into more long term solutions and come up with something to sustain us through the short term. I would gladly pay $.01 more state sales tax if could ensure that early childhood education would be saved. There are other options, and those options NEED to be explored before making cuts to such necessary funding.

Money, Money

Posted by Concerned Taxpayer, Traverse City, MI - Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 4:46 p.m.

I would hate for early education programs to be cut. I would hate for unemployment to be cut, for food stamps, public safety services, etc to be cut. They are all essential services and extremely important. But where is the money going to come from if they don't make some cuts. I am not saying they should cut these programs but there isn't any money to give them. This state is broke and they can't give people money they don't have.

Parents it is time to step up and be the parents, that is why you had children....right!!!!!

Posted by Traverse City Traverse City, Traverse City - Thursday, July 16, 2009 at 4:41 p.m.

Funding for day care should not be cut! That funding allows parents to go to work and make money to provide for their families.
Funding for early childhood education should be cut!!!! What ever happened to parents being parents? Let's sit down with our kids and teach them to read, write, spell, know their numbers and letters. By that time they will be in public school and with capable teachers.
There are so many parents out there complaining because their children's funding for early childhood education is being taken away......STEP UP AND TEACH YOUR CHILDREN YOURSELF, you would be very surprised at what your kids can and will learn from you if you actually put some effort into it. Oh and by the way, you may actually have fun teaching your kids!

News
ADVERTISEMENT

PopularCommented


CONSUMER INFO